The actress – who is known for her blazing rows and public spats with ex-girlfriend Samantha Ronson – is said to have got into an altercation with New York Rangers ice hockey players Aaron Voros and Sean Avery as she partied at 1Oak nightclub for the Wildfox Fall Collection party last Thursday (13.05.10).
The 23-year-old star reportedly threw her drink over Aaron's model girlfriend Jessica Stam before trying to get them ejected from the club.
A source told the New York Post newspaper: "Lindsay threw a fit because she wanted to be at their table near the DJ. But she claimed she didn't want to sit with Aaron and said, 'He's my ex-boyfriend. I don't want him anywhere near me.'
"A drink then flew in Jessica's face, and Lindsay demanded their table be moved out. Club bosses refused and tried to calm her down. Stam, Voros and Avery were shocked but didn't retaliate, and Lindsay left shortly afterwards."
Another source claimed the troubled star – who was recently banned from the Trousdale club in Los Angeles for throwing a glass at Samantha – threw a fit for "absolutely no reason."
Aaron has since denied even knowing the actress.